2012 Toyota 4Runner Review and Prices

Last Updated: Aug 5, 2010

Like this Review

2012 Toyota 4Runner Buying Advice

The 2012 Toyota 4Runner is the best SUV for you if you’re loyal to the fading breed of body-on-frame SUVs and want one of the best.

The 2012 Toyota 4Runner isn’t apt to get any major change compared to the 2011 Toyota 4Runner. It’ll remain a tall-riding wagon with seating for up to seven and a skill set that runs from off-road clambered to on-road coddling. It’s frankly better at the former, and unless you regularly continue driving after the pavement runs out, a lighter-duty crossover is probably your better bet in an everyday SUV.

Should you wait for the 2012 Toyota 4Runner or buy a 2011 Toyota 4Runner? This SUV was all-new for model-year 2010; it didn’t change much for model-year 2011, and it’s a little too early in the lifecycle to expect significant alterations for model-year 2012. So there seems little reason to wait for the 2012 4Runner. The 2011 4Runner has the brake-override system Toyota began installing after the sudden-acceleration safety recalls. The 2011 4Runner also will launch while Toyota is still offering tempting cash incentives as part of its safety-recall recovery campaign. The styling of the 2012 4Runner, meanwhile, could have a relatively short shelf life before a minor freshening is expected around model-year 2013.

2012 Toyota 4Runner Changes back to top

Styling: The 2012 Toyota 4Runner will be a visual repeat of the 2011 4Runner except for a possible new color choice or two. This is a square-rigged wagon with a bulldog nose and bulging fenders. The styling compliments 4Runner’s classic-SUV engineering, in which a wagon body attaches to a separate truck-type frame. Body-on-frame construction suits the rigors of off-roading and trailer towing. But it’s fallen out of fashion in favor of crossover SUVs that combine body and frame into a “unibody” structure similar to that used on cars. Unibody construction is space-efficient and its weight savings benefit fuel economy, ride, and handling. Toyota’s product portfolio is diverse enough to accommodate both the 4Runner and the softer-natured 2012 Toyota Highlander, a midsize seven-seat crossover SUV with no off-road pretense but friendlier on-road manners. The 2012 4Runner will continue with four side doors and a liftgate that’s the only in any sort of midsize SUV to feature a power-down rear window. Size wise, the 2012 4Runner will continue to fall roughly in the middle of the midsize-SUV class. Roughly 50 percent of midsize SUVs can accommodate more than five passengers and the 2012 4Runner will again be among these. It has two front bucket seats, a three-passenger fold-down second-row bench, and an optional fold-down third-row bench sized most appropriately for young children. The 2012 4Runner’s interior design should continue to reflect its exterior character, with blocky shapes and oversized control knobs. This SUV’s off-road-ready ride height makes getting in or out a chore. Once aboard, 4Runner’s cabin is hospitable enough if you’re sitting in the first two rows and especially if you’ve ordered the leather upholstery and tapped into the nice array of available amenities. Expect the 2012 4Runner lineup to again consist of three models. The base version will likely keep its SR5 label. The 2012 4Runner Trail model should return visually distinguished by front and rear bumpers contoured to more easily clear off-road obstacles. Remaining atop the line should be the 2012 4Runner Limited model with chrome grillework and 20-inch alloy wheels fancier than the other models’ 17s.

Mechanical: The 2012 Toyota 4Runner is likely to mirror the mechanical features of the 2011 4Runner. That means it’ll carry over with a 4.0-liter V-6 and five-speed automatic transmission as its sole powertrain. Expect horsepower to remain 270 and torque 278 pound-feet. (Torque is crucial in a heavy vehicle such as the 4Runner; think of it as the force that propels you forward and horsepower as the energy that sustains momentum.) Toyota wisely discontinued 4Runner’s available four-cylinder engine in model-year 2011. At 157 horsepower and 178 pound-feet torque and linked with an archaic four-speed automatic transmission, the four was for those who seldom strayed from the intersection of Slow Lane and Never Climb Hills. The V-6 makes for a livelier 4Runner, though still not one that passes slower traffic with authority or makes you forget it’s saddled with 4,500-4,900 pounds of body-on-frame SUV. Tow ratings for the 2012 4Runner will likely remain an unremarkable 5,000 pounds or so. Key 4Runner rivals offer V-8s with a minimum of 388 pound-feet of torque for better all-around acceleration and more trailering power. Expect the 2012 4Runner’s road manners to continue to make concessions to its traditional-SUV design. The body-on-frame weight, tall-sidewall tires, long suspension travel, and slow steering conspire to dull reactions when you want to turn. The truck-tough solid rear axle can’t match the typical crossover’s all-independent suspension for ride comfort and control. And 4Runner’s bluff body shape compromises directional stability in strong crosswinds. 4Runner’s old-school-SUV philosophy pays dividends once you leave the pavement, however. Unlike crossovers, which typically are based on front-wheel-drive engineering and employ light-duty all-wheel-drive systems, 4Runner’s authentic-SUV design defaults to rear-wheel drive and uses 4wd to share power with the front wheels. In fact, the 4Runner SR5 and Trail models have a rather elementary 4wd system in which the driver pulls a floor lever to engage the front wheels. This so-called part-time 4wd is only for use off-road or in extremely slippery conditions. Expect “full-time” 4wd to remain reserved for the 4Runner Limited model. This more sophisticated 4wd system can be left engaged on any surface and is activated by a center-console switch. Regardless of system, all 4wd 2012 4Runners will again invite real off-roading thanks to separate low-range gearing and Toyota’s Active Traction Control (A-TRAC) system. Trail models, meanwhile, will continue with advanced terrain-matching software and hardware. (See “2012 Toyota 4Runner Prices” below for details.)

Features: It might not drive like a car-type crossover, but the 2012 Toyota 4Runner won’t lack for most every modern convenience. Expect the 2012 standard-equipment list to again include air conditioning, a tilt/telescope steering wheel, power locks, and power windows – including that power tailgate window. Remote keyless entry cruise control, and 10 cup and bottle holders also will be standard. So should an audio system with satellite radio and a “Party Mode” setting that biases tailgate-mounted speakers for outdoor listening. 4Runner’s second-row folding bench seat is split 40/20/40 and has a reclining backrest. Seven-passenger seating is available on V-6 models via an optional 50-50 folding third-row bench. Also available for easier loading and tailgate parties is a slide-out cargo-floor tray that supports up to 440 pounds. The 2012 4Runner Trail and Limited models should again expand on the SR5’s standard equipment list by adding steering-wheel audio controls, USB interface for iPods, and Bluetooth phone and music-streaming connectivity. The 2012 4Runner Limited will return with keyless entry and pushbutton start standard; it’ll also feature Toyota’s X-REAS suspension that automatically adjusts shock-absorber damping over bumps or when cornering.  Leather upholstery with heated power front seats will likely be standard on the Limited and optional on the SR5; the Trail model should continue with water-resistant fabric upholstery. Other equipment standard or optional depending on model will again include a voice-activated touch-screen DVD navigation system with a 7-inch dashboard monitor, power tilt/slide moonroof, and a rear-view monitor that displays on the inside mirror. All 2012 4Runners will again come with antilock four-wheel disc brakes and traction and antiskid systems for better control in stops, take-offs, and sharp turns. Front passengers will again get knee airbags, and all three seating rows will get head-protecting side curtain airbags. Toyota’s Safety Connect with automatic collision notification and stolen-vehicle locator services will again be available by subscription. Expect all 2012 4Runners to retain fuel-tank skid plates.

2012 Toyota 4Runner Prices back to top

Toyota won’t announce 2012 4Runner prices until shortly before the vehicle goes on sale. But based on this SUV’s history expect a 2012 Toyota 4Runner base-price range of roughly $31,000-$41,500. (Estimated base prices in this review include the manufacturer’s mandated destination fee. Toyota’s fee for the 2011 4Runner was $810. Toyotas sold in some Southeastern and Gulf states are supplied by independent distributors and may carry different destination fees.)

Estimated starting price for the 2012 Toyota 4Runner SR5 is $31,000 with 2wd and $33,000 with 4wd. (Note that the discontinued four-cylinder 4Runner was offered only as a 2wd SR5 model and started around $28,300.)

The 2012 Toyota 4Runner Trail model will be priced from an estimated $37,000. Estimated starting price for the 2012 Toyota 4Runner Limited is $39,000 with 2wd and $41,500 with 4wd.

More than a few SUVs – including a few crossovers – have styling that snarls “off-road ready.” But 4wd 4Runners will never be accused of being paper tigers. Hill-start assist will likely return as standard on 2012 V-6 4Runners and downhill assist will again be standard on SR5 and Limited 4wd models. Expect all 2012 4wd Toyota 4Runners to continue with a generous 9.6 inches of ground clearance and standard A-TRAC, which can sustain momentum on irregular or slippery terrain by distributing driving force to any wheel in contact with the ground.

The 2012 4Runner Trail model’s standard equipment list should again suit serious off-roaders. Expect it to retain its electronic-locking rear differential and Toyota’s Crawl Control. A sort-of terrible-topography cruise control with five driver-selectable speeds, Crawl Control automatically maintains slow, constant progress to maximize driver confidence and minimize suspension and drivetrain loads. Also standard on the 2012 4Runner Trail model will be Toyota’s Multi-Terrain Select. This automatically dials in an appropriate amount of wheel slip to sustain progress in sand or mud, over dry rock, or on other challenging surfaces. Finally, expect the 2012 4Runner Trail model to again be available with Toyota’s Kinetic Dynamic Suspension System. This disconnects 4Runner’s stabilizer bars to allow greater axle travel and better suspension articulation for improved performance on irregular terrain.

2012 Toyota 4Runner Fuel Economy back to top

Official 2012 EPA mileage estimates were not released in time for this review, but expect 2012 Toyota 4Runner fuel-economy ratings to change little from those of earlier models in this design generation.

That suggests fuel-economy ratings for the 2012 Toyota 4Runner of 17/23 mpg city/highway with 2wd and 17/22 mpg with 4wd. Interestingly, at a rated 18/23 mpg, the four-cylinder alternative to 4Runner’s V-6 wasn’t present so much to boost fuel economy as to create a lower price of entry.

2012 Toyota 4Runner Release Date back to top

The 2012 Toyota 4Runner should go on sale by autumn 2011.

What's next for the 2012 Toyota 4Runner back to top

Based on Toyota’s track record of seven-year lifecycles for trucks, the 4Runner would receive a “mid-cycle” freshening around model-year 2013, close out this fifth-generation design in model-year 2015, and be all-new for model-year 2016.

Don’t expect any mid-cycle freshening to go beyond minor styling revisions, maybe some new cabin surfaces, and perhaps a bit of features-sharing among trim levels. Wild speculation would involve the addition of a turbocharged four-cylinder to hike power without too much penalty in fuel economy. Slightly less wild speculation would envision the return of a V-8 engine option. More reasonable conjecture has Toyota tweaking 4Runner’s existing engines to improve fuel economy and, if possible, for a bit more power. An upgrade in transmissions – to a six-speed automatic for both engines – would be our recommendation.

As for the sixth-generation 2016 4Runner, we think Toyota is loyal enough to this shrinking niche to stick with body-on-frame construction. It offers a sufficient range of crossover alternatives within its own showrooms to satisfy SUV buyers who don’t care about going off-road (or projecting an off-roader image). And it has a portfolio of rear-drive trucks roughly this size – including America’s best-selling compact pickup in the Tacoma -- from which it could draw components and realize cost efficiencies.

It’s a good bet the next-generation 4Runner will be smaller than today’s model. We’re not convinced it needs three rows of seats, but it certainly it needs to be lighter. It’ll probably retain four- and six-cylinder power, and if Toyota holds true to its promise to offer a hybrid version of every vehicle it makes, the next-generation 4Runner lineup will include a gas-electric model.

2012 Toyota 4Runner Competition back to top

Nissan Pathfinder: This body-on-frame SUV counters 4Runner point-for-point with five- or seven-passenger seating, tough-guy styling, and off-road oriented 4wd systems. It arguably handles better than the 4Runner, and still offers a choice of V-6 or V-8 engines – at least through model-year 2012. In a radical change, Nissan’s expected to recreate the 2013 Pathfinder as an all-new crossover SUV. That doesn’t necessarily dictate a loss of off-road ability but it does suggest a major change in driving character. Another one bites the dust.

Jeep Grand Cherokee: Exhibit-A that off-road excellence doesn’t require body-on-frame construction is Jeep’s flagship SUV. Fully redesigned for model-year 2011, Grand Cherokee retains a fortified unibody structure and teams it with a range of 4wd systems, including one with state-of-the-art terrain-response. Just as significantly, Grand Cherokee goes upscale, with Euro-flavored design inside and out, premium-quality cabin appointments, and a handling-tuned suspension. Six- and eight-cylinder engines are on the job.

Ford Explorer: A good choice in a comfortable seven-seat crossover that nicely updates traditional-SUV styling and retains all the off-pavement capability most drivers will ever need. Explorer was fully redesigned for model-year 2011, shedding its body-on-frame design and available V-8 engine for a Taurus-based platform. Ford’s EcoBoost turbocharged four-cylinder is the optional choice from the standard V-6 and all-wheel drive (AWD) the alternative to front-wheel drive. On road refinement is Explorer’s objective, but AWD models come standard with a Ford’s Terrain Management System that automatically adjusts to suit a multitude of slippery conditions.

2012 Toyota 4Runner Next Steps